ADManager Plus vs SolarWinds ARM

The Decision Swiss IT Teams Are Making

Three dimensions no current comparison addresses together: vendor security track record, market momentum trajectory, and cloud-native readiness, evaluated through the lens of nFADP, where you bear personal liability of up to CHF 250,000.

READ TIME · 5 MIN

Updated May 2026

KIDAN Engineering Team

1,300+ Deployments · 93.8% Retention

ADManager Starting Price (Published)

$ 0

Pre-built Compliance Reports

0 +

SolarWinds ARM Critical CVEs (2024)

Personal Liability Under nFADP

CHF 0 K

Swiss IT teams shortlisting Active Directory management tools are routinely handed two narratives: SolarWinds Access Rights Manager as the feature-rich option, ManageEngine ADManager Plus as the cost-effective one. Neither framing tells the full story – and the gaps are consequential for anyone making a decision in a Swiss regulatory environment.

This article covers three dimensions that no current comparison addresses together: the vendor security track record differential, the market momentum trajectory, and the cloud-native readiness gap – evaluated through the lens of nFADP, where individual IT leaders bear personal liability of up to CHF 250,000 per violation. By the end, you will have a complete decision framework – not just a feature table.

At a Glance

Four Numbers That Define This Decision

Before you read another word, these four data points frame everything that follows.

ADManager Plus Starting Price - Fully Published

$ 0 /yr

vs $1,650+ for SolarWinds ARM

ADManager Market Mindshare - Growing YoY

0 %

SolarWinds ARM: 4.5% - Declining

Critical CVEs in SolarWinds ARM (2024, CVSS 9.6)

ADManager Plus: Zero comparable disclosures

ADManager Compliance Report Generation

0 S

200+ pre-built reports - no scripting needed

Data sourced from PeerSpot Active Directory Management Category Report (April 2026), Arctic Wolf CVE advisory (July 2024), and ManageEngine official pricing.

What Each Product Is Actually Built For

ADManager Plus is built for IT teams that need unified identity governance across AD, Microsoft 365, Exchange Online, and Google Workspace, without scripting. SolarWinds ARM is built primarily for file server permissions auditing in on-premises environments with dedicated AD specialists on staff.

ADManager Plus is a web-based platform for managing Active Directory, Microsoft 365, Exchange Online, and Google Workspace from a single console. Built for IT teams that need unified identity governance without scripting or professional services overhead. Pricing starts at $595/year and is publicly published — before any sales contact.

SolarWinds Access Rights Manager

(originally 8MAN, acquired 2018/2019) is an on-premises access rights management platform built primarily for auditing, file server permissions visualisation, and AD user provisioning. Pricing starts at $1,650 with the full edition from $3,448+. Enterprise pricing requires a quote

Feature Comparison: Where ADManager Plus Leads

Feature Matrix

ADManager Plus vs SolarWinds ARM: Head-to-Head

Every cell cross-referenced against official product pages, PeerSpot verified reviews, and named security advisories. Verified as of mid-2026.

Feature

Pricing Transparency

Microsoft 365 Management

Google Workspace

Exchange Online Config

Scripting Required

Pre-built Compliance Reports

Mobile App

Free Trial

UI Generation

Deployment Model

File Server Auditing

Critical CVEs (2024)

Market Mindshare (Apr 2026)

ADManager Plus

$595/yr - Published

Native, unified console

Native

None - point-and-click

200+ out-of-box

iOS & Android

30-day, full features

Modern web-based

On-prem / SaaS

Yes

None disclosed

14.5% — Growing ↑

SolarWinds ARM

$1,650+ Quote-only

Limited / complex setup

Not supported

Documented as difficult

Some automation workflows

Customisable, fewer OOB

Not available

30-day available

Legacy (user-reported)

On-prem primary

Yes (key strength)

8 Critical CVSS 9.6

4.5% — Declining ↓

Source: PeerSpot Active Directory Management Category Report (April 2026) · Arctic Wolf & The Hacker News (July 2024) · ManageEngine official documentation.

Market Momentum: The Direction the Market Is Moving

Market Momentum

Mindshare Trajectory
ADManager Plus vs SolarWinds ARM

PeerSpot Active Directory Management Category, April 2026. The market has chosen a direction. ADManager Plus is growing. SolarWinds ARM is declining.

ADManager Plus — Growing ↑

2025

0 %

2026

0 %

SolarWinds ARM — Declining ↓

2025

0 %

2026

0 %

ADManager Plus mindshare gain YoT

+ 0 %

SolarWinds ARM mindshare loss YoY

- 0 %

ADManager mindshare advantage over ARM

0 x

Source: PeerSpot Active Directory Management Category Report, April 2026.

Why It Matters According to KIDAN

Mindshare decline in a niche B2B category is a leading indicator. IT teams are switching away from ARM in meaningful numbers — and the reviews tell you why: legacy UI, complex configuration, cloud-native gaps, and pricing opacity. ADManager Plus’s growth reflects the opposite: teams who want modern tools that work without a dedicated AD architect.

The Security Track Record: The Factor Nobody Publishes

In July 2024, SolarWinds patched 13 vulnerabilities in Access Rights Manager – 8 rated Critical at CVSS 9.6, allowing unauthenticated remote code execution, directory traversal, and authentication bypass. ADManager Plus has no comparable supply chain incident and no ARM-equivalent critical vulnerability disclosure history.

No existing comparison article addresses this dimension in a structured way. It belongs in any honest assessment of a tool with privileged access to Active Directory – the identity backbone of your entire organisation.

Security Track Record

Vendor Security History: A Direct Comparison

When a tool has privileged, domain-wide AD access, the vendor’s security history is a personal risk management decision – especially under nFADP’s individual liability framework.

ADManager Plus

ManageEngine · KIDAN's deployed platform

No critical vulnerability disclosures comparable to ARM's 2024 patch cycle

No supply chain incident in ManageEngine's product history

Trusted by 1,300+ Swiss organisations across financial services, healthcare, and public sector

Regular security updates with transparent release notes — no emergency patch cycles

KIDAN deploys and audits ADManager Plus in production daily - we stake our reputation on it

SolarWinds ARM

SolarWinds · Original vendor: 8MAN

July 2024: 13 vulnerabilities patched in ARM, 8 rated Critical at CVSS 9.6

SUNBURST 2020: SolarWinds Orion supply chain attack (separate product — ARM not affected, but same vendor)

All 2024 vulnerabilities patched in ARM v2024.3 — current versions are maintained

Vendor trust posture remains a legitimate CISO consideration for any tool with privileged AD access

No critical vulnerability disclosures comparable to ARM's 2024 patch cycle

⚠ July 2024 ARM Vulnerabilities — ARM v2024.3 Patch Required

CVE-2024-23472 — Unauthenticated Remote Code Execution

CVE-2024-28074 — Directory Traversal / Arbitrary File Deletion

CVE-2024-23469 — Authentication Bypass

5 additional Critical CVEs — same patch cycle

Sources: Arctic Wolf security advisory (July 2024) · The Hacker News (July 2024) · KIDAN production deployment experience.

KIDAN’s Perspective Made Simple

We are not suggesting SolarWinds ARM is unsafe in its current patched state. We are noting that vendor trust history is a legitimate procurement criterion for any tool with privileged AD access – particularly in Switzerland’s regulatory environment where you carry personal liability under nFADP. Every CISO we work with at KIDAN evaluates vendor security posture alongside product features. This section exists because no other comparison article does.

The Swiss Compliance Dimension

This is not just a software decision. Under nFADP, it is a personal liability decision.

Switzerland's revised Federal Act on Data Protection (nFADP, SR 235.1), in force since 1 September 2023, holds directors, IT managers, and system administrators personally liable - fines up to CHF 250,000 directed at individuals, not just legal entities. The tool that has privileged access to your AD is part of that liability picture.

Personal fine under nFADP - directed at individuals, not just legal entities

CHF 0

ADManager Plus pre-built compliance reports — audit-ready in 60 seconds

0 + Reports

Swiss ICT professional shortage (Swico/IWSB 2024) - VBScript dependency compounds this

ADManager Plus provides 200+ pre-built audit and compliance reports – access certification campaigns, risk exposure management, identity risk assessment — that generate audit-ready documentation in one click. Under nFADP’s personal liability framework, audit readiness speed is not a convenience feature — it is a direct risk management variable.

Switzerland faces a documented shortage of 25,000 ICT professionals (Swico/IWSB 2024). A tool that requires scripting expertise or complex configuration — as ARM does for advanced workflows – is not just a technical limitation. It is a hiring dependency that compounds an already scarce talent market.

Total Cost of Ownership: What the Price Tags Don't Show

3-Year Total Cost of Ownership

The Real Cost Gap
Licence Is Just the Starting Point

Every competitor comparison focuses on licence cost. None of them quantify the total cost gap. On a 3-year basis, the differential is wider than the licence comparison alone suggests.

✅ ADManager Plus

Starting Licence (yr 1)

$595/yr

Pricing Transparency

Fully published

Setup Complexity

Low

Scripting Skills Needed

None

Professional Services

Optional

Trial / Procurement

Self-serve, 30 days

Support (24/7)

Included

Lower 3-yr TCO

Across licence + skills + implementation

⚠ SolarWinds ARM

Starting Licence (yr 1)

$1,650+/yr

Full Edition

$3,448+ quote

Setup Complexity

Medium–High

Scripting Skills Needed

Some workflows

Professional Services

Often required

Trial / Procurement

Sales-engaged eval

Enterprise Pricing

Quote-only

2.8× Higher Entry

Before enterprise pricing or PS costs

2.8×

SolarWinds ARM entry cost vs ADManager Plus — before enterprise pricing, PS, or scripting overhead

Source: PeerSpot head-to-head comparison report (July 2025) · TrustRadius verified reviews · ManageEngine and SolarWinds official pricing pages.

KIDAN's Expert Note

When evaluating AD management tools, always request a 3-year total cost projection – not just licence fees. Include implementation time, admin skills overhead, and the cost of delayed deployment due to procurement friction. For most Swiss mid-market organisations we work with, this calculation changes the decision entirely.

Get Your Free 3-Year TCO Assessment

KIDAN’s engineers provide a complete cost projection – licence, PS, scripting overhead, and implementation effort – free for Swiss organisations evaluating ADManager Plus.

Which Tool Is Right for Your Environment

Decision Framework

The Choice Framework
Built on 1,300+ Swiss Deployments

Neither product is universally superior. But for the vast majority of Swiss mid-market and enterprise teams – the answer is clear.

Choose ADManager Plus

Managing AD alongside Microsoft 365 and/or Google Workspace

Need 200+ pre-built compliance reports for nFADP, FINMA, or GDPR in <60 seconds

Modern, mobile-accessible web console - no scripting for any core workflow

Budget transparency and fast procurement - no sales call for a 30-day trial

Team of 1–15 IT admins without dedicated AD architects

Time-to-deployment and time-to-value are operational priorities

Vendor security track record is a procurement criterion for your CISO or board

Consider ARM Only If

Deep file server permissions auditing is your primary and dominant use case

You have a dedicated security team with capacity to manage ARM's configuration complexity

You run SAP alongside AD and need integrated SAP system monitoring

Already embedded in the SolarWinds ecosystem with in-house ARM expertise

Budget is secondary to file server audit depth and you have the implementation resources

Decision framework based on KIDAN’s 1,300+ Swiss enterprise deployments across financial services, healthcare, manufacturing, and public sector.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is SolarWinds Access Rights Manager safe to use after the 2020 SolarWinds hack?

ARM is a separate product from SolarWinds Orion, which was the target of SUNBURST – ARM was not affected. However, in July 2024, ARM itself contained 13 vulnerabilities – 8 rated Critical at CVSS 9.6 – patched in ARM 2024.3. Current maintained versions are patched. Vendor trust posture remains a legitimate CISO consideration for any tool with privileged AD access – particularly in Switzerland’s regulatory environment where IT leaders bear personal liability under nFADP.

What is the price difference between ADManager Plus and SolarWinds ARM?

ADManager Plus starts at $595/year with fully published tier pricing — no sales call required. SolarWinds ARM starts at $1,650 (perpetual or subscription), with the full edition from $3,448+. Enterprise ARM pricing is quote-only. On a 3-year total cost basis — including setup, admin skills overhead, scripting dependency, and procurement time — the differential is significantly wider than the licence comparison alone. KIDAN provides free 3-year TCO assessments for Swiss organisations.

Can SolarWinds ARM manage Google Workspace?

No. SolarWinds ARM does not support Google Workspace. ADManager Plus manages Active Directory, Microsoft 365, Exchange Online, and Google Workspace natively from a single web-based console. For any Swiss organisation running a hybrid environment that includes Google Workspace – increasingly standard in education, media, and technology — ARM is structurally excluded from the shortlist.

Which has better compliance reporting for Swiss organisations under nFADP?

ADManager Plus provides 200+ pre-built compliance reports – covering access certification, risk exposure, inactive accounts, and identity governance – generating audit-ready outputs in under 60 seconds. ARM’s reporting is customisable but requires more setup. Under nFADP’s personal liability framework (CHF 250,000 per violation, directed at individuals), audit readiness speed is a direct personal risk management variable. ADManager Plus wins this dimension clearly.

Which is easier to deploy for a mid-market IT team?

ADManager Plus is rated consistently easier to deploy with lower initial setup cost in PeerSpot’s head-to-head comparison data (July 2025). It is typically operational within days for standard environments, with a 30-day full-feature trial available without a sales call. KIDAN’s implementation team can have ADManager Plus fully configured – including directory integration, provisioning templates, and compliance report setup — within a single engagement.

The Verdict — KIDAN's Assessment

For Swiss IT Teams, ADManager Plus Is the Operationally Correct Choice.

The three factors that matter most — vendor trust history, market momentum trajectory, and cloud-native readiness — compound in the same direction. For Swiss organisations managing hybrid AD environments under nFADP, with cloud workloads growing and IT teams sized for execution rather than architecture projects, that compounding matters. The majority of organisations evaluating these two tools do not have a primary file server permissions audit challenge. They have a unified identity governance challenge across AD, Microsoft 365, and Google Workspace — in a regulatory environment where personal liability is real and audit readiness timelines are tight. That is the profile ADManager Plus is built for. KIDAN deploys, implements, and supports ADManager Plus for Swiss organisations across financial services, healthcare, manufacturing, and enterprise IT — 1,300+ deployments and counting.

Written by

KIDAN Security Team

Switzerland's largest ManageEngine Partner - 1,300+ customers, 93.8% retention rate. Daily production deployments of ADManager Plus across Swiss financial services, healthcare, and public sector. Fluent in German, French, and English.

As a Service

Partner Program

IAM

Cloud

UEM

MSP

Security

...........

Help Desk

Networks

.....

....

IT Analytics

AlarmsOne

ManageEngine

IAM

AD360

Access Manager Plus

ADManager Plus

ADSelfService Plus

Access Manager Plus

Key Manager Plus

Identity 360

PAM360

Password Manager Pro

Recovery Manager Plus

IAM

UEM

Security

Networks

Cloud

MSP

Help Desk

IT Analytics

ColorTokens

Cloudflare

SentinelOne

Microsoft

Horizon3

Zoho

Xink

Sangfor

390+

115+

1'300+